Post-Paris Attacks: Governments Push for Access to Encrypted
⦁ Rachael King
Commercial technology that enables encrypted communications again is
coming under scrutiny following Friday’s terrorist attacks in Paris, as
authorities worry that they may not have the ability to intercept
intelligence on future attacks, according to the Journal.
Some businesses, though, have resisted further surveillance by nation
states. One objection is that governments could use such access for
economic gain by stealing corporate intellectual property. At the G-20
Summit in Turkey, Monday, leaders said that international law applies to
state conduct in cyberspace and that no country should conduct or
support cyber-enabled theft of intellectual property with the intent of
providing competitive advantages to companies or commercial sectors.
This is an important first step if there’s going to be balance between
national security globally and competing economic interests, said David
Burg, the global cybersecurity leader at PwC, who talked with CIO
Journal Tuesday. Below is an edited transcript of the conversation.
The Paris attackers may have used encrypted messaging to communicate
without being detected. Will there be an increased call by governments
to have keys to encrypted communications for national security purposes?
I think we have a situation that I’d describe as very much like a
pendulum. In the wake of the Snowden disclosures, we saw the privacy
pendulum swing pretty far in one direction. When you see an event like
what occurred in Paris, it really makes tangible the reasons why various
government agencies need to have an ability to intercept and be able to
read certain kinds of electronic communications. So, I think what we’re
going to see as a consequence of Paris is that the pendulum is going to
wind up shifting, perhaps for some time, in the other direction.
These attacks do make the case, perhaps, that under the right kinds of
controls or conditions, that law enforcement or intelligence agencies do
in fact need to have an ability to be able to peer into electronic
messaging and communications. The other point here is that these secure
communications technologies are becoming incredibly common, if not
ubiquitous. This is one of the reasons why I think we’ll see this
pendulum shifting.
I think there will be quite a bit of a chorus from many developed
nations, maybe even at the G-20 meetings this week that we need more
unified agreement on how developed nations around the world can agree on
how – in a controlled manner – intercept and to be able to understand
and interpret all forms of electronic communication. The pendulum is
always modulated by privacy activists and I think those are important
views.
Many other countries were upset with the U.S. government’s surveillance
activities. There were implications for U.S. based companies doing
business globally. How do you create rules that give law enforcement in
different countries access to encrypted corporate communications?
What was signed yesterday as part of the G-20 was an agreement among
members that cyberattack techniques would not be used for conducting
economic espionage. That’s an incredibly important starting premise. If
we’re talking about national security and being able to intercept
communications for the sake of national security, that’s one of those
moderating functions. It’s really hard to govern that type of an
agreement. But I think that G-20 agreement is extremely important
because you move away from a country by country dialog and discussion
and into a collective discussion about how G-20-type nations can work
together in a coordinated way with respect to national security.
Are there any consequences for breaking that agreement?
The application and enforcement are extremely important…While, in
principle, what was signed in the G-20 is traveling the right course, I
think the reality is that the actual implementation and monitoring and
compliance is really where the rubber meets the road. Those will be
incredibly important steps to watch going forward for that agreement to
become tangible and make as much sense as it should.
Where are we right now in the ability for people and companies to
encrypt communications and the ability for governments to decrypt them?
I think we’re at a tipping point. I think that’s what these Paris
attacks show is that you have some smart individuals who have studied
carefully and have been able to take advantage of commercial
technologies anyone can buy. It depends, on an individual level on your
stance on privacy, your knowledge of these types of tools and how to use
them.
One of the paradoxical consequences of the Paris attacks could be that
more regular citizens become aware that they can in fact use these
technologies to go dark. Many more individual citizens may be able to
take advantage of these over the counter technologies that will enable
them to go dark in the eyes of either U.S. law enforcement or
intelligence agencies.
Privacy is a good thing when human beings have no intention of harming
one another. Privacy can become an umbrella under which bad actors can
hide and, it appears, did hide in connection to these Paris attacks.
That’s where the privacy rights become a national security issue and
that’s right at the heart of this debate. We have to figure out where
you draw the line.
Some companies have been vocal about not wanting any government to snoop
on their services or their communications. What do you say to those
companies?
I think we have to be very careful about absolutes in any measure.
Making a statement that under no circumstances should people who use a
certain type of security app or service be able to be identified, I
think is dangerous.
What we’re talking about is protecting individuals who are working
within the system of commerce that is very important for economic
security. When people play by the rules, the rules should work fairly.
We need to have the options to operate differently with people who
operate [far outside the norm].
Write to rachael.king@wsj.com
http://blogs.wsj.com/cio/2015/11/18/post-paris-attacks-governments-push-for-access-to-encrypted-communications/