Broad Powers Seen for Obama in Cyberstrikes
WASHINGTON — A secret legal review on the use of America’s growing arsenal
of cyberweapons has concluded that President Obama has the broad power to
order a pre-emptive strike if the United States detects credible evidence of
a major digital attack looming from abroad, according to officials involved
in the review.
That decision is among several reached in recent months as the
administration moves, in the next few weeks, to approve the nation’s first
rules for how the military can defend, or retaliate, against a major
cyberattack. New policies will also govern how the intelligence agencies can
carry out searches of faraway computer networks for signs of potential
attacks on the United States and, if the president approves, attack
adversaries by injecting them with destructive code — even if there is no
declared war.
The rules will be highly classified, just as those governing drone strikes
have been closely held. John O. Brennan, Mr. Obama’s chief counterterrorism
adviser and his nominee to run the Central Intelligence Agency, played a
central role in developing the administration’s policies regarding both
drones and cyberwarfare, the two newest and most politically sensitive
weapons in the American arsenal.
Cyberweaponry is the newest and perhaps most complex arms race under way.
The Pentagon has created a new Cyber Command, and computer network warfare
is one of the few parts of the military budget that is expected to grow.
Officials said that the new cyberpolicies had been guided by a decade of
evolution in counterterrorism policy, particularly on the division of
authority between the military and the intelligence agencies in deploying
cyberweapons. Officials spoke on condition of anonymity because they were
not authorized to talk on the record.
Under current rules, the military can openly carry out counterterrorism
missions in nations where the United States operates under the rules of war,
like Afghanistan. But the intelligence agencies have the authority to carry
out clandestine drone strikes and commando raids in places like Pakistan and
Yemen, which are not declared war zones. The results have provoked wide
protests.
Mr. Obama is known to have approved the use of cyberweapons only once, early
in his presidency, when he ordered an escalating series of cyberattacks
against Iran’s nuclear enrichment facilities. The operation was code-named
Olympic Games, and while it began inside the Pentagon under President George
W. Bush, it was quickly taken over by the National Security Agency, the
largest of the intelligence agencies, under the president’s authority to
conduct covert action.
As the process of defining the rules of engagement began more than a year
ago, one senior administration official emphasized that the United States
had restrained its use of cyberweapons. “There are levels of cyberwarfare
that are far more aggressive than anything that has been used or recommended
to be done,” the official said.
The attacks on Iran illustrated that a nation’s infrastructure can be
destroyed without bombing it or sending in saboteurs.
While many potential targets are military, a country’s power grids,
financial systems and communications networks can also be crippled. Even
more complex, nonstate actors, like terrorists or criminal groups, can mount
attacks, and it is often difficult to tell who is responsible. Some critics
have said the cyberthreat is being exaggerated by contractors and
consultants who see billions in potential earnings.
One senior American official said that officials quickly determined that the
cyberweapons were so powerful that — like nuclear weapons — they should be
unleashed only on the direct orders of the commander in chief.
A possible exception would be in cases of narrowly targeted tactical strikes
by the military, like turning off an air defense system during a
conventional strike against an adversary.
“There are very, very few instances in cyberoperations in which the decision
will be made at a level below the president,” the official said. That means
the administration has ruled out the use of “automatic” retaliation if a
cyberattack on America’s infrastructure is detected, even if the virus is
traveling at network speeds.
While the rules have been in development for more than two years, they are
coming out at a time of greatly increased cyberattacks on American companies
and critical infrastructure. The Department of Homeland Security recently
announced that an American power station, which it did not name, was
crippled for weeks by cyberattacks. The New York Times reported last week
that it had been struck, for more than four months, by a cyberattack
emanating from China. The Wall Street Journal and The Washington Post have
reported similar attacks on their systems.
“While this is all described in neutral terms — what are we going to do
about cyberattacks — the underlying question is, ‘What are we going to do
about China?’ ” said Richard Falkenrath, a senior fellow at the Council on
Foreign Relations. “There’s a lot of signaling going on between the two
countries on this subject.”
International law allows any nation to defend itself from threats, and the
United States has applied that concept to conduct pre-emptive attacks.